Cubs closer questions resurface in 5-4 loss to Giants

SAN FRANCISCO – The Cubs trudged off the field as the Giants mobbed Wilmer Flores, who had just drawn a bases-loaded walk to win the game. When the Cubs fell to the Giants 5-4 on Monday, closer questions resurfaced – if they had ever gone dormant.

“They hit some balls in some good places in the ninth, and then the walks hurt us, frankly,” manager Craig Counsell said after the Cubs’ 18th one-run loss of the year. “They obviously hurt us bad. The ninth inning did not go well.”

It was a movie the Cubs had seen before. They got a strong outing from their starting pitcher, failed to capitalize on opportunities to run up the score, and then their bullpen blew the save opportunity. Rinse, wash, repeat.

Over the past week or so, Counsell has gone with more of a closer-by-committee approach. Veteran right-hander Héctor Neris seems to have gone from Counsell’s first choice in save opportunities to one of several options. Counsell said Neris was available Monday, but the manager instead went to right-hander Colten Brewer and lefty Drew Smyly in the ninth.

“I think we’re all just trying to figure it out, patch it together,” Smyly said.

The Cubs went into the bottom of the ninth with a two-run lead. The Giants had rolled out an entirely right-handed hitting lineup against Cubs lefty starter Justin Steele, who held San Francisco to two runs through 7 ⅓ innings. So, against the Giants' No. 5-7 hitters in the ninth inning, Counsell called on Brewer.

He gave up a leadoff double to Matt Chapman on a blooper that landed just out of the reach of diving center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong. Then Thairo Estrada put down a bunt single, and pinch-hitting Michael Conforto hit a sacrifice fly to cut the Cubs’ lead to one.

Anticipating Giants manager Bob Melvin’s possible moves, Counsell suspected switch-hitting Patrick Bailey was available to pinch hit against a left-handed pitcher, or Brett Wisley against a right-hander.

Counsell chose to have Smyly face Bailey, and he said he liked the matchup between Smyly and the next man up, Nick Ahmed.

Smyly induced Bailey to hit a ground ball, but it got through the infield up the middle. Then he walked Ahmed to load the bases. A sacrifice fly, intentional walk and unintentional walk later, the Cubs left the field with a 37-42 record.

“Tough loss,” Smyly said after the game. “I wish I would have been more over the plate. They all felt really close, but they did a good job not chasing, staying in their approach.”

Smyly, who has been a starter for most of his career, and Brewer, who signed a non-roster invitee deal with the Cubs this winter, weren't brought on to be shutdown closers. But between injuries and performance, the current bullpen construction is forcing multiple relievers into uncomfortable spots. Cubs relievers have combined for 17 blown saves, the second-most in the majors, behind only the White Sox (21).