Child born during international flight to US sparks heated debate about citizenship, legal identity

A woman gave birth midair Friday on a flight from Kingston, Jamaica, to New York, turning a routine plane trip into a high-altitude drama.

The mother aboard a Caribbean Airlines flight had a successful delivery, as Fox News Digital previously reported — but shortly after the unexpected arrival, a hot debate about the baby's citizenship commenced. 

"Sometimes, when a child is not born in a hospital and there's no birth record, that can create problems," Cyrus D. Mehta, a New York-based immigration attorney told Fox News Digital. (He is not connected to the Caribbean Airlines case.) 

FLIGHT PASSENGERS SLAM AIRLINES FOR PUSHING EARLY BAG CHECKS EVEN WITH EMPTY BINS ON BOARD

Even so, he added, "it's very clear. If you're born in the territory of the United States, even if it's on an airplane, you are a citizen," he continued.

"The question is: What constitutes U.S. airspace?" he also said. 

Commenters online debated the issue.

"Is this baby an American?" wrote one person. "Was it born in American airspace? Does that qualify? Seems every other situation possible qualifies under the ‘birthright’ citizenship. What a joke!"

Said another person about the Caribbean Airlines birth, "If the parents are American citizens, then the baby is."

CLICK HERE FOR MORE LIFESTYLE STORIES

Wrote another commenter, "Good example of why the [Supreme Court] needs to rule Trump's [executive order] as valid. These are not isolated cases — they happen every day of the week. Non-citizens know they'll win the lottery if they can give birth while in the U.S."

Caribbean Airlines notes on its website that expectant mothers can travel on their planes without a doctor’s approval until the end of their 32nd week of pregnancy — but travel is not permitted beyond the 35th week. 

Even so, incidents in which women give birth on flights are very uncommon. 

A March 2020 study published by the Journal of Travel Medicine found that between 1929 and 2018, there were 74 in-flight births across 73 commercial flights — with 71 of those newborn infants surviving.

TEST YOURSELF WITH OUR LATEST LIFESTYLE QUIZ

The primary reason most airlines do not want pregnant women to fly very late in their pregnancies is medical. 

Other procedural issues can occur as well, Mehta said.

Proof of the precise location of the plane during childbirth midair and the moment the baby is born can be challenging.

The government requires a log from an airline or ship "reflecting the latitude and longitude when the birth occurred," Mehta said. 

"The parent is responsible for reporting the birth to authorities" — and the parents will need a birth certificate if they want to obtain a passport for the child, he added.

Caribbean Airlines said that, while the birth aboard its flight was unexpected, the crew never declared an emergency during the trip. 

Instead, the airline praised its crew, who "managed the situation in accordance with established procedures, ensuring the safety and comfort of all onboard."

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER

The airline said the woman and newborn received the care they needed from medical personnel.

The unusual childbirth comes at a time of heated discussion about citizenship laws in the United States.

The Supreme Court recently heard oral arguments on a challenge to President Donald Trump’s Executive Order 14160, which limits birthright citizenship in the U.S.

Section one of the 14th Amendment automatically grants citizenship to all persons born in the United States. 

The courts have routinely upheld birthright citizenship for over a century.

Ashley J. DiMella and Lorraine Taylor, both of Fox News Digital, contributed reporting.