F-22 Raptor vs. YF-23: The Intense Competition Behind America's Next Stealth Fighter
Summary: The Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor and the Northrop Grumman YF-23 were fierce competitors in a 1980s bid for a U.S. Air Force contract to develop a stealthy, supercruise-capable fighter jet.
-Despite the YF-23 demonstrating superior stealth capabilities, range, and a higher operational ceiling, the F-22 won the contract due to its impressive in-flight demonstration, which included missile launches and high-G maneuvers that were not performed by the YF-23.
-The decision also leaned on Lockheed Martin's perceived better project management track record. However, subsequent evaluations by Congress revealed that the F-22 program faced significant delays and budget overruns, contradicting the initial confidence in Lockheed's project management abilities.
Why the F-22 Raptor Won Over the YF-23 in the U.S. Air Force's Stealth Jet Face-Off
The Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor, one of the best fighter jets of all time, once had some stiff competition. The YF-23 was a stealth fighter demonstrator that gave the F-22 a run for its money when both were tested for service in the U.S. Air Force and went head to head for a massive contract.
The F-22 eventually won, but it is illustrative to examine how this competition paved the way for the advent of the F-22 Raptor.
Let’s take a look at the YF-23 and see why some thought it was the superior fighter. Perhaps it could have beat the F-22 and have come in on time and under budget.
A Tough Competition Between Two Heavyweight Teams
It was the 1980s and the U.S. Air Force was looking for an airplane that was stealthy and performed better than the F-15 and F-16.
The Air Force was worried about 4th generation Soviet fighters such as the Su-27 and MiG-29.
The branch wanted a supercruise capability that allowed for top speed without the use of afterburners. This would reduce heat signature with less fuel and create higher levels of radar evasion.
The Air Force put out a bid for the $72 billion program and two competing platforms came forward in 1986. Northrop Grumman paired up with McDonnell Douglas while Lockheed Martin, Boeing, and General Dynamics formed the competing team.
Northrop-McDonnell Douglas then came up with the YF-23A while Lockheed-Boeing-General Dynamics devised the YF-22A, or what would be the F-22 Raptor. The Lockheed team had an idea to test two different engines, so they built two different prototypes. One was a Pratt and Whitney model, called the Black Widow II, while the other was from General Electric and became known as the Grey Ghost. Both used turbofan engines.
YF-23 Demonstrator Performed Better
The YF-22 was a little faster at around 1,600 miles per hour, while the YF-23 prototypes had a 2,796 miles maximum range and a ceiling of 65,000 feet, plus better stealth characteristics. The YF-22 had a lower range and lower ceiling. So initially, the YF-23 looked like a winner. But the in-flight demonstration was where the YF-22 shined. The YF-22 launched missiles and put the Lockheed model through tests that placed 9Gs on the airframe. For some reason, the YF-23 did not go through the same maneuvers. Some said the YF-23 even was a better-looking airplane.
It was like two football wide receivers had the same size and 40-yard dash speed, yet one competitor actually ran routes and caught touchdown passes during the practice. So, the Air Force went for the better in-flight demonstration and chose the YF-22. It seemed that much of the YF-22 success in the competition was due to “showmanship.”
Ironically, Lockheed Martin and F-22 were chosen in part because the Air Force thought it had a better track record in managing a major aircraft acquisition program. But Congress, reacting to a Government Accountability Office 2001 report, found that the F-22 was not on an adequate testing schedule and was delayed and over-budget. Go figure.
About the Author
Brent M. Eastwood, PhD, is the author of Humans, Machines, and Data: Future Trends in Warfare. He is an Emerging Threats expert and former U.S. Army Infantry officer.